Sunday, July 5, 2015

How many stars

In honor of the holiday weekend and the stars and stripes, here's a little bit about how I rate books, specifically on Goodreads.  The rating system on Goodreads allows for a rating of between one and five stars.  Here are my definitions for those stars:

Five stars is reserved for books that I truly love.  The ones I read over and over again and never get enough of.  Books like The Outsiders, A Tree Grows in Brooklyn, To Kill A Mockingbird.  The ones that made me fall in love with reading and writing.

I have to seriously enjoy a book to even give it four stars.  The last book I gave four stars was Me Before You by Jojo Moyes, which I finished with tears streaming down my face.  If a book moves me enough to want to tell someone "You have to read this book," I will give it four stars.

My go to rating is three stars.  If I read a book and enjoy it enough to pass it on to a friend or family member, it gets three stars.  It probably didn't blow me away, but it was a decent read.

Two stars is dipping into dangerous territory.  Generally a two-star rating goes to a book that I had to force myself to finish.  I tend to give a book fifty pages before dropping it.  If I get past 50 pages, and still end up not enjoying it, that's a two-star book for me.

Like the five-star, a one-star rating is rare for me.  I have to genuinely hate a book to rate it one star. There have been a couple of book club reads that I ended up rating one star.  I actually finished one about an hour before our meeting, muttering "I hate this book," as I slogged my way through the final pages.  I won't mention the name of the book, but I will never read a book by that author again. 

Even more rare than a one-star is a book I can't finish.  I have a hard time with this, because I always want to give a book a chance to change my mind.  But in the interest of saving time, I came up with my 50 page rule.  If I get 50 pages into a book and still can't find a redeeming quality in it, I will put it down.  I don't even bother rating these, I just remove them from my Goodreads list.

No comments:

Post a Comment